5 Good Ways & 1 Bad Way to Get Your Ducts Inside Conditioned Space

9 Comments Read/write comments

ducts inside conditioned space

I'm a big advocate of getting ducts inside the building enclosure. In cooling climates, getting ducts out of an unconditioned attic can save you 15% on your electricity bills. It can reduce the size of air conditioner you need by 25%. If it's not in such a harsh environment, your air conditioner will last longer, too. But how do you do it?

First, I'll show you 5 acceptable ways to do it. Below is a diagram from the paper by Dave Roberts and Jon Winkler of the National Renewable Energy Lab (NREL) that I wrote about a while back. (That's also the paper that the above statistics come from.)

ducts inside building enclosure 4 approaches

In the first approach, you move the building enclosure to the roofline so the attic becomes conditioned space. The second one shows a lowered ceiling or soffit in the house, and that keeps the ducts below the attic. The third shows ducts between conditioned floors in a multi-story house. The fourth shows them in the attic, sort of, but below the building enclosure with some help from a special type of truss.

beautiful duct system in a beautiful crawl space

Another method, which isn't shown in that paper from NREL, is to put the ducts in a conditioned crawl space, as shown above. This was a house that I visited in Nashville recently.

I've just shown you the bare minimum here. The devil is indeed in the details, though, and you're in luck. The Earth Advantage Institute out in the Northwest (US) has put together a great resource for designers, builders, trade contractors, or anyone trying to figure out exactly how to get your ducts inside the conditioned space. They have a website called Ducts Inside, and it's packed with great information: implementation strategies, a training manual, case studies, and more. Check it out!

Finally, let's get to that one bad way to get ducts inside that I promised you. The photo below, from HVAC hacks and other screwups, shows it in all its glory.

ducts in conditioned space hack 440

Wow! Uh...that isn't really what we mean when we say to put the ducts inside. Yes, they're definitely in conditioned space, but I have a hard time trying to figure out how someone decided to do this.

The truth is that there are many ways to get your ducts inside the conditioned space. As with anything, though, it can be done by a hack or it can be done by a pro. Don't be a hack.

Addendum: A word on new homes vs. existing homes

Getting the ducts into conditioned space is much easier when you can do it in the design phase of a new home. Once the house is built and the ducts are installed, your options are greatly reduced. If the ducts are in an unconditioned attic, you can put spray foam insulation on the roof deck. If the ducts are in an unconditioned crawl space, you can encapsulate. As Don Peek says in the comments below, it may be more cost-effective in existing homes to seal and insulate the ducts as well as you can.

 

Related Articles

Case Closed: Get Those Air Conditioning Ducts out of the Attic

Beautiful Duct System in a Beautiful Crawl Space! Was I Dreaming?

Snakes in an Attic — The Ductopus's Cousin Strangles Bath Fans

 

Comments

Don Peek

Very well done and straight to the point! 
However, to change the location of existing duct work can be very difficult and expensive. Many times just sealing the existing ducts and adding enough blown in fiberglass insulation to cover them is a better value.

Allison Bailes

Don P.: Yes, I should have mentioned the issue of existing homes vs. new homes initially, and your comment spurred me to add that to the article. Thanks, Don.

geoff hartman

Covering ducts with blown insulation can have unintended consequences in hot/humid climates. Even properly insulated ducts can start to sweat & drip causing water damage and 'microbial growth.'

Allison Bailes

geoff h.: Yes, that issue has come up before in comments to our blog. John Tooley even commented about it here. I've threatened to write an article about that issue and haven't gotten around to it yet. Thanks for the reminder! 
 

Cameron Taylor

With existing homes, many times it's just not possible to get ducts out of the attic without considerable expense and mess. Therefore either reflective roofing (cool roof) or cathedralized insulation are the sane choices here. My experience with reflective roofing on my own pad has been positive; attic temperatures seldom run higher than outdoor ambient temperatures, and a/c supply air temperatures show little gain from plenum to most remote supply air register. House can be maintained at a 75 degree setpoint on 1st stage on a 100 degree day with ease. 
 
For new construction, ducts in attics should be completely eliminated. There's no excuse to not accomodate them within conditioned space, but it's hard to buck the tide in this area. It doesn't get prospective home buyers to sign contracts, for the most part, so the ducts get thrown into the attic to make way for granite countertops and commercial range hoods.

Anthony Hyde

Here in SE PA there are large numbers of new (and not so new) homes with the second HVAC system in the attic outside the thermal envelope. Local code officials require both the HVAC unit and all ductwork to be above the insulation on the ceiling below. Often the equipment platform is not raised to allow full insulation depth and the flex duct is sagging between supports after leaving the body of he "ductopus". Lousy design and installation is OK, as long as you can see the entire system - so how do they allow ducts between floors and inside walls? 
 
However, there are good local HVAC contractors. Recent new home duct testing for single systems, 2400 sq ft, low 20's CFM25. Larger 5500 sq ft with 2 systems and total combined duct leakage of 54 CFM25.

Ryan Shanahan

We (Earth Advantage) worked with NEEA to create ducts inside dot org: http://ductsinside.org/ 
There are lots of great (free) downloadable documents that cover these same concepts with greater detail for builders and design teams.

Steve Waclo

Allison, 
 
Thanks for making time to pen (?) yet another informative and entertaining article. A twe-fer, if you will. 
 
Regarding the linked article, "Beautiful Duct System...", there is a photo of a system in an encapsulated crawl space showing provisions for supply off one of the trunk lines. We're any special provisions made for return air? 
 
I encapsulated my 2002 crawl space a few years back after I discovered a 4" supply line had been installed vertically from the attic distribution system. The floor above the crawl was so well sealed, there was no air flow from the 4" duct unless the closet crawl space access was open and I finally installed a return grill there. 
 
Warm(er) hardwood floors in the heating season are wonderful and no discernable effect on heating costs. Would have been hard to notice unless it was dramatic. 
 
Let me know about return air provisions. 
 
All the best.

Allison Bailes

Cameron T.: Yeah, keeping the heat out of the attic to start with is a great strategy if you're not going to encapsulate the attic. I wrote about shingle temperature and attic ventilation for Green Building Advisor a few weeks ago, and there's some good info there about this topic. 
 
Anthony H.: Yeah, I've seen a lot of attic HVAC systems like you describe. It's nice that things are changing a bit, at least with some contractors, though. 
 
Ryan S.: That's a wonderful resource! Here's a clickable link:  
 
Steve W.: Yes, that house had a transfer grille through the floor so the air put into the crawl space could make its way back into the house and through HVAC system. That's how Joe Lstiburek did it in his house, too.